Spying on Fish Love Calls Could Help Protect Them from Overfishing

About a third of the world’s fish stocks are being overfished, meaning they’re being harvested faster than they can reproduce, and species that spawn seasonally in large groups are especially vulnerable, easy for fishers to locate and plucked from the water often before they’ve seeded the next generation.

A team led by marine scientists from The University of Texas Marine Science Institute (UTMSI) and the Scripps Institution of Oceanography at the University of California San Diego have discovered a way to use the incredibly loud, distinctive sounds that fish make when they gather to spawn—not to catch them but to protect them. The team developed an inexpensive yet accurate method for estimating how many fish are in a spawning aggregation, based on their mating calls. Accurate data on when and where fish spawn, as well as how many there are, would help fisheries managers design effective management practices and monitor the ongoing health of a fishery.

“It can be extremely challenging to get a complete picture of fish spawning events because they can happen over very short to very long times and are often in difficult environments such as murky water,” says Brad Erisman, assistant professor at UTMSI and senior author of a study published June 13 in the journal Scientific Reports. “Our work opens an acoustic window into these exciting spawning events.”

The paper’s lead author is Timothy Rowell, a graduate student of Octavio Aburto-Oropeza’s at Scripps.

The researchers developed the method specifically for the Gulf corvina, a popular fish in Mexico’s Gulf of California, but it can be adapted to any fish that make courtship sounds such as cod, groupers and croakers, including the endangered totoaba, a species that is also endemic to the Gulf of California.

Each spring, the entire adult population of Gulf corvina—more than 2 million fish—migrates to a small area at the northern tip of the Gulf of California. When the males start calling to attract mates, the sound is deafening. Using underwater microphones called hydrophones, Rowell discovered that these fish can make sounds up to 192 decibels—enough to damage your eardrums if it were on land.

“It's louder than a rock concert,” says Erisman. “It’s louder than standing less than a meter from a chain saw.”

Hear the spawning sounds of the Gulf Corvina and learn more about the research on the Point of Discovery podcast:

All that noise is dangerous to the fish, too, because it leads fishers right to the corvina spawning aggregations. Over about 20 nights each spring, they can harvest more than a million fish with minimal effort. Because the entire species spawns in one place, they are extremely vulnerable.

Until now, it has been difficult to monitor the population, but there is anecdotal evidence that illegal fishing is on the rise and that the fish being caught are getting smaller over time, both signs that they might be overfished.

“Over-harvesting from the aggregation site could result in the functional extinction of the species in the ecosystem, which would have negative effects on the local economy and cause the fishery to collapse,” says Rowell. “This is why sustainable harvest levels need to be set. At the moment we do not know what these levels are.”

Rowell and Erisman’s new acoustic method for monitoring spawning populations could help ensure that corvina fishing is sustainable in the long run.

“The fishers are by no means the enemy here,” says Erisman. “They're actually the ones who have provided us with all the information and access to the resource, and they're the ones most interested in sustainability.”

Erisman and Rowell are part of an international research group, the Gulf of California Marine Program, that has created an interactive online tool called dataMARES where anyone can study how corvina populations are changing. And those who fish, fisheries managers and conservationists can now do a better job of keeping corvina populations sustainable.

“The idea is we try to bring all the stakeholders, different groups that have a vested interest in the fishery and the environment, together to try to work it out,” says Erisman. “And it's nice that science is playing a role in that.”

Erisman and Rowell’s co-authors are David Demer and John Hyde of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration’s Southwest Fisheries Science Center; Octavio Aburto-Oropeza of the Scripps Institution of Oceanography; and Juan José Cota-Nieto from Centro para la Biodiversidad Marina y Conservación A.C.

The project was funded in part by grants from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, the Walton Family Foundation and the David and Lucile Packard Foundation.

MORE INFO

One way to accurately measure the number of fish in a spawning aggregation is to use sonar, a system that sends out high-frequency sounds and, based on the sounds reflected back, estimates the density and numbers of fish. But sonar is expensive and time-intensive, and its results are difficult to analyze.

The scientists found a way to achieve the accuracy of sonar in a simpler, less expensive way. They went out on nights when the corvina were spawning and used hydrophones to simultaneously collect both sonar data and sound intensities of fish calls. They discovered that during peak spawning times, there was a linear relationship between the two kinds of data. Now, going forward, scientists can measure sound intensities alone and, with a simple mathematical equation, estimate in real time the density and numbers of fish.